US: Ohio Supreme Court Upholds Bank Tax, Protecting $1.3 Billion Revenue Stream

Ohio Supreme Court Leaves Financial-Institutions Tax Intact

The Ohio Supreme Court has upheld the state’s financial-institutions tax, rejecting a challenge brought by Dollar Bank, FSB and allowing the tax framework to remain in place.

In Dollar Bank, FSB v. Harris, the court ruled that Ohio’s financial-institutions tax under Chapter 5726 of the Ohio Revised Code is internally consistent and does not unfairly discriminate against interstate commerce. The court therefore affirmed the decision of the Board of Tax Appeals, which had upheld the tax commissioner’s denial of Dollar Bank’s refund request.

What Was the Bank Challenging?

Dollar Bank had argued that Ohio’s tax structure violated the Dormant Commerce Clause of the US Constitution by placing an unfair burden on banks involved in interstate commerce.

The case focused on whether the tax system would create discriminatory treatment when applied across jurisdictions. The Supreme Court rejected that argument, concluding that the tax is internally consistent.

The decision provides important clarity for financial institutions operating in Ohio and reinforces the state’s authority to maintain its existing taxation framework.

Implications for Ohio Banking

Ohio’s financial-institutions tax has generated more than $1.3 billion over six years, making it an important source of state revenue.

The ruling means banks operating under the state’s financial-institutions tax framework will continue to face the existing tax obligations unless lawmakers make future changes.

For Ohio, the decision provides greater certainty around a significant revenue source. For banks, however, it underscores the continuing importance of understanding state-level tax exposure when operating across multiple jurisdictions.

The ruling also highlights the broader tension between state taxation, interstate banking and constitutional limits on discriminatory tax policies.